Pi Day Paradox

Here’s the infamous “proof” that shows that  π is equal to 4.

pi_4

The zig-zagged polygon, whose perimeter always remains 4, does appear to approach the circle as we repeat these steps to infinity. Ergo, π is equal to 4!

The problem, as Vi Hart explains in this amusing math doodle video, is that while the area of the polygon does approach the area of the circle, the actual perimeter of the polygon is much larger than the circumference of the circle. Confused? Think of it this way: if you put a jumbled up 10 feet long rope into a 1 foot long container, you wouldn’t say that the rope is now 1 foot long, would you? You would take out the rope, and extend it fully to measure its actual size.

See some more discussion here. Also, here’s another video that “proves” — using a similar approach — that π is equal to 2, and the square root of 2 (another one of my favorite irrational numbers) is also equal to 2!

***

By the way, if π were actually equal to 4, all circles would be squares. What a terrible world that would be! Similarly, if π were equal to 3, all circles would be hexagons. (For a hexagon, the ratio of its circumference to its diameter is equal to 3.)

Oh, and happy pi day! Don’t forget to have some delicious pie, and as you eat it, marvel at the glory of this magnificent, transcendental, and most importantly, irrational number.

i ate some pie***

Previously on this blog: Proof Without Words IVHappy Pi Day 20133.14A Sanskrit Mnemonic for πHappy Pi Day!A Mathematical Conundrum.

Happy Pi Day 2013

comic2-987

From this year onwards, in addition to celebrating Pi Day on March 14th, I am going to celebrate Pi Approximation Day on July 22nd (22/7) as well. I can really use an additional day of celebration for my favorite mathematical constant!

By the way, here’s an interesting approximation of π: A nano-century is approximately π seconds long. In other words, if you divide the number of seconds in a century by one billion (nano = 1 billionth), you’ll get a result that’s close to π:

One nano-century is approximately π seconds long.

***

The comic is from Dinosaur Comic.

Previous posts involving π: 3.14, A Sanskrit Mnemonic for π, Happy Pi Day!, A Mathematical Conundrum.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 66 other followers

On Twitter

Categories