Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na and Ada – Initial Reaction

I have been listening to Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na and Ada since last two days, and here’re some of my initial thoughts:

Kabhi Kabhi Aditi is a catchy, light and peppy number. I loved it in the very first listen (on the promos). Although Rashid Ali did a commendable job and his voice suits well to the movie’s young and fresh look, I wish Rahman had given this song to Adnan Sami. I think this song belonged to Adnan. (Isn’t Rashid Ali’s singing seem to have inspired from Adnan?) The rationale behind not using Adana though is probably that they wanted to have a new voice for the new face (i.e. Imran Khan) – at least for this ‘opening’ song. 

Rahman has re-used one of his own tunes for this song. The mukhda of Kabhi Kabhi Aditi is same as the guitar interlude in Mustafa Mustafa song from the movie Duniya Dilwalon Kee. I am actually glad that he has done that (i.e. re-using one of his tunes from the interludes of his own song). There are many song by arr which has wonderful instrumental (or chorus) interludes that can be used to create a mukhda of new song (The violin interlude in Ae Ajnabi, Swarnalatha’s humming in Sunta Hai Mera Khuda, chorus from the starting of the song Naheen Saamne etc. etc. etc.)

Jaane Tu Mera Kya Hai conveys the melancholic mood effectively. I liked the version sung by Sukhwinder more than the one sung by Runa Rizvi (which is also very good), mostly because of the opening music/tempo and the operatic chorus in the background that takes it to another level. (The techno beats of Runa Rizvi verion reminded me of songs of Tehzeeb.)

Pappu Can’t Dance has a very catchy tune and feet-tapping beats. However, I don’t think it’s gonna be one of those songs that I will yearn to hear in a way I feel about most (or at least, so many) of arr’s songs.

After a long time, arr gives us a smooth jazzy number, sung by himself, Tu Bole Main Boloon. A very enjoyable track sprinkled with saxophone background and light drum beats. (Is Vennila Vennila from Iruvar the only other jazz song by arr?)

Abbas Tyrewala has done a good job as a first time lyricist (His earlier work includes dialogues for Munnabhai M.B.B.S.). I really liked that he used the immortal lines ‘Papa Kehte Hain Bada Naam Karega’, giving a nod to Aamir Khan’s first movie: Qayamat Se Qayamat Tak. (JTYJN is Aamir’s nephew Imran’s first movie.)

Moving on to the other album released simultaneously with JTYJN – Ada.

Rashid Ali’s pronunciations in Ishq Ada sounded a bit weird to me. I think he tried to add an Arabic/Middle-Eastern element to the song – the lyrics, heavy on Urdu words, also confirms this (I hope there’s some relevance to that in the movie.)

All songs except Ishq Ada and Meherbaan are written by Nusrat Badr. I was excited to see his name on album cover because I loved his work in Devdas (after which he almost disappeared). But honestly, I didn’t find anything extraordinary in his lyrics this time.

Gumsum Gumsum sounds infinitely ordinary (by arr standards). If Ada is a musical journey by arr, then this surely is the worst destination. Tu Mera also belong to the same category. (The lines ‘Jise Chaha Mil Gaya’ sung by Chitra reminded me – both lyrically and musically – of similar lines ‘Tu Mujhko Mil Gaya’ from Tera Jaadu Chal Gaya. Vague similarity, though.) 

Meherbaan is wonderful and instantly likable. Hai Dard and Milo Wahan Wahan both are, for the lack of better word, interesting – both in structure and sound, very unlike-Rahman, I think (and hope, even more so) these ghazal-like songs has some ‘growth potential’. Rahman has rarely used Sunidhi before (in fact, only once in Nayak) who joins Sonu Nigam in Gulfisha – another song that didn’t really impress me.

Overall I am disappointed with Ada, and enjoyed JTYJN. As it’s universally known, arr’s songs (specially the “heavy”, deep and long-lasting ones) need repeated hearings and some time to grow on you. Being an ardent arr fan, I hope that it will happen this time too, and my initial assessments will be proven wrong. But deep down, I am skeptical!


4 responses to “Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na and Ada – Initial Reaction

  1. You have made the review of Ada a little too technical, find out what others have to say about Ada here.

  2. vishal12


    I haven’t written much about Ada at all. These are some of my initial reactions (as the title of the post suggests) after few listens. It was not meant to be a full-fledged music review.

    I will read the review/s that you’ve referred to. Thanks for your comment.


  3. a fantastic album..my choice for the best music of 2008..jaane tu mera kya hai of runa rizvi will rock the charts

    Read my review here:

  4. TJ

    I agree with your assessment of Ada, an album coming from ARR is definitely the subject of curiosity coupled with anticipation. Overall Ada was disappointing except the rendition of “Ada Hai” by Parul Mishra. Mind you, its an extremely difficult song to sing with many intricate Harqats (isnt that expected for all ARR songs though !!!) and she has indeed done a fabulous job at that.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 66 other followers

On Twitter


%d bloggers like this: